Marketing & SEO Discussion List - LED Digest

 
LED Digest 2309: SEO Scumbaggery Print E-mail
==================================================
                 The LED Digest
             Moderated Discussion List
     "Effective Online Advertising, Since 1997"

      Data > Information > Knowledge > Wisdom

         pair Networks: The LED's Web Host
Hosting and Domain Registration from a Trusted Leader
  pair.com for Hosting  |  pairNIC.com for Domains

==================================================
List Moderator:                     Published by:
Adam Audette                          LED Digest
adam, led-digest.com     http://www.led-digest.com
..............................................
December 15, 2006                   Issue no. 2309
..............................................


            .....IN THIS DIGEST.....


====== NEW =====================

        --== SEO Scumbaggery ==--

                ~ Moderator Comment>
"What good are top rankings if your site is
down and being held hostage?"


==== CONTINUING =================

        --== Online Marketing for Classical Musicians ==--

                ~ Shel Horowitz
"...how can we do for classical music what
Dannon did for yogurt...?"

                ~ David Spahr
"...Canon in D by Johann Pachebel is the fourth
most viewed YouTube video ever..."

        --== The Email Crisis ==--

                ~ Steven Birk
"The worst thing ever invented...was the
mailto: link..."

                ~ Mark Frank
"The solution is William Bontrager..."

        --== Website Accessibility ==--

                ~ Tom Aman
"I do not really like dropdown menus on
Web pages..."


========== NEW ===================================

<Moderator Comment>

SEO Scumbaggery

I spoke with an LEDer today that needed help with some SEO work.
He's in a very defined niche selling a unique retail item. There's
not a ton of competition and his site is ranking fairly well. At
least it *was* ranking well...

He described to me over the phone some of the work he's had done by
other SEO companies. The most recent firm did two lame things: they
guaranteed him specific top rankings and required him to host his
site on their servers. I explained that 1) no one can *guarantee*
rankings, and 2) no legitimate SEO wants to host their client's
sites (that I know of).

In dealing with him - he was a very bright person, friendly and
obviously well-meaning - I got the feeling I was talking to a brick
wall a little. His site was ranked fairly high - 2nd page in Google
and 1st page in Yahoo (didn't check MSN or Ask) for his targeted
keyphrases. But once I did some digging I found a few things:

- Some strange stuff that appeared to be .org domains hosted on the
same server and pointing to his IP. With pages and pages of links /
anchor text.

- Some obviously paid-for links to unrelated domains.

- etc. I didn't want to look any further.

When I explained that this kind of aggressive SEO can fail you long
term when / if the search engines change their algorithms to
compensate for such vulnerabilities, he pretty much said "but I have
good rankings." Yup, hard to argue with that - but for how long??
And how much risk?

Now he's in a financial dispute with the shady SEO, who has
retaliated by *taking his site down and holding it hostage*! They
don't have admin control of his domain name, luckily, but they do
control the site and he has to either cough up some cash or start
from scratch!

I'm doing some scratching myself... of my head. What good are top
rankings if your site is down and being held hostage?

Any other tales of SEO Scumbaggery out there?

Have a great weekend,
Adam


======== CONTINUING ===============================

From: Shel Horowitz
Subject: Marketing music

> People under 35 or so in the mass-consumer market countries
> have pretty much written off serious music as being hopelessly
> un-cool. Even so-called "cross-over" classical musicians face
> tremendous obstacles... Anything "smart" has now been tainted
> by pop culture as being of interest only to girls who cannot get
> a date, nerds and old people.
        - David Yancey, LED Digest 2308
        - http://www.led-digest.com/content/view/1403/55/

Well, my area may be an anomaly -- but around these parts (western
Massachusetts, admittedly a college and culture area), there's a
thriving classical music scene for kids. When my daughter played
piano as part of a benefit concert for the Golden Mountain Chamber
Music Academy, the various acts, ages 12 or so through college
except for the faculty, filled a good-sized church. My son was
concertmaster (head violinist) of one youth orchestra last year and
this year he is principal oboist of another. Maybe it's the circles
we travel in, but we know more kids who do classical music than who
do sports. Most of them are female, but my son is far from the only
boy.

And at least the more serious among these kids do listen to
classical music on their own time. They also listen to rock,
hip-hop, etc. Their peers don't always understand the music, but the
do admire skill on any instrument, in any genre.

Maybe the real challenge is to prove to the world that classical
music is fun. Disney's Fantasia helped create a mass audience for
classical in the 30 and 40s. Carl Sagan turned the arcane science of
astronomy into pop culture. Dannon made yogurt sexy in the 70s.

Like my son, I'm very eclectic in my musical taste. I'll listen with
equal fervor to the Who, Joan Baez, and Beethoven. And when I think
about the utter joy of spirit I hear listening to our amateur
recording of my daughter playing Debussy's "La Catedral" -- at least
as sexy as Dannon yogurt, for goodness sake -- or my son reaching
the high notes on the Vaughan Williams oboe concerto -- all I can
think of is that those who've never exposed themselves to this
beautiful music are missing out, deeply.

So, marketers of the world -- how can we do for classical music what
Dannon did for yogurt, once the nerdiest of nerdy foods? One small
step I've taken is to put up over 20 articles in the classical music
section of my Global Arts Review on the FrugalFun.com website.

Shel Horowitz
http://www.business-ethics-pledge.org


-------- new post - same topic --------

From: David Spahr
Subject: Marketing classical music

> As far as the larger market goes... I'm not persuaded that
> serious music can compete for eyeballs (or eardrums) in
> sites and communities like MySpace, much less Youtube.
        - David Yancey, LED Digest 2308

This video on youtube of Canon in D by Johann Pachebel is the fourth
most viewed youtube video ever with almost 12 million views:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QjA5faZF1A8 .

Amazing what a young college student can do from his bedroom in
Korea. OK, not traditional but still a true virtuoso. If this guy
can't give you food for thought... Follow the links around and find
lots of classical musicians.

David Spahr
* Stereoviews.com * Antique-Photography.com


-------- new post - new topic --------

From: Steve Birk
Subject: Email

> Do you have a nice code that us morons could use
> to take the place of "mailto:' that is more secure?
        - Peter D'Aprix, LED Digest 2304
        - http://www.led-digest.com/content/view/1394/55/

Regarding Peter's request for some alternatives of using something
other than a mailto: link... I posted the below alternatives back in
LED 2128 in March of this year [see
http://www.led-digest.com/content/view/343/55/ -ed].

These are just a few alternatives that I found that you may find
useful:

First thing...

http://willmaster.com/possibilities/demo/RetrieveEmails.cgi and
enter your page URL and see if a Spam-bot has the possibility to
find your address. If you have an email address on the page you
search (whether you have tried to hide it or not) and this finds it,
for sure a Spam-bot will find it. Not saying its 100% accurate, but
it's a start...

Alternative Number 1:

Look at http://www.automaticlabs.com/products/enkoderform This looks
like it has quite a robust way of encrypting your email address and
its free. It does encrypt it inside of JavaScript so there may be
some who don't want to use it for that reason. I tested it on a page
and used the willmaster url above as a test and it did not find it.
Not saying that's 100% fool proof, but it's something...

Alternative Number 2:

You can also use:
http://www.golivecentral.com/pages/txttut/scramble.shtml This will
ASCII encode your email address, but you MUST embed it inside
JavaScript to hide it from the spambots. Do not just encode the
mailto: link in ASCII and use it as an ordinary HTML link, as the
spambots will find this.

Alternative Number 3:

Another option is at:
http://accessfp.net/protect-your-email-address.htm Look about 1/2
way down the page under the "Solution for Stopping Spam-Bots from
Obtaining your Email Address from your Website" section. This
produces a non-clickable link, but a copy and paste-able email
address that your visitor can easily use to paste your email address
into their email program, but which is undetectable by a Spam-bot.

(NOTE: I also found that you should never put just your email
address as text on your web page as a Spam-bot will find that also.
Use 'Number 3' above if you want to produce a non-clickable, visible
email address on your web page).

IMHO, if I had a web site that did not have a contact form and
wanted to have my email address visible on my site for people to
contact me, I would use Number 3 above. If someone is too lazy to
copy and paste my visible email address into their email program,
then they probably don't want to contact me that bad... The worst
thing ever invented, again IMHO, was the mailto: link... and I'm
sure if those who invented this link knew what spam was back then,
they would have skipped this feature.

I have no affiliation with the above links; I just found them and
included the actual links as a possible solution to just having a
plain old mailto: link clearly visible in your source code.

The only real way to kill these harvesters off is to starve them! Do
what ever you can TODAY to protect your email address(s) on your web
sites -- try one of the three methods above and never stop looking
for more! But... I'm sure there are those hot on the trail to hack
into your email address even if you use any of the methods above...
It unfortunately is never ending.

I hope this may help.

Regards,

Steven Birk, FF/EMT
http://publicsafetyhub.com/emergencycard
Free emergency contact card - don't leave home without it!


-------- new post - same topic --------

From: Mark Frank
Subject: Email

Peter,

The solution is William Bontrager (http://willmaster.com).  He has
cgi form handlers that solve the junk mail problem.  They come with
great installation instructions if you want to install them or he
will install them for you at a very reasonable price.

He also has a good overview of spam-proofing options at
http://www.bontragercgi.com/Spam-Proofing_Your_Web_Site.html.

Mark Frank, Author

Start Your Own Home Based Website Design Business
http://www.websitedesignbiz.com


-------- new post - new topic ---------

From: Tom Aman
Subject: Accessibility

> There is absolutely no reason why a text
> reader cannot work its way through javascript.
        - Al Toman, LED Digest 2308

Sorry to disagree, but there is lots of reasons why a text reader
would have problems attempting to deal with javascript.  While some
script is very simple and could be dealt with, a lot of it involves
calls to various functions and the resulting output can often vary,
sometimes depending on the user choices made on the page.

For example, your post mentions javascript dropdown menus.  How
would a text reader render something like that in a way that would
make sense to the surfer???  The problem here is that it would make
no sense to voice the dropdown content unless the mouse was pointing
at the appropriate menu item and the pointer may well have moved on
to the next item before the text reader has finished with the first
one.  I could see this becoming incredibly confusing to the surfer.
And that is just one example.

(FYI, I do not really like dropdown menus on Web pages, however they
are created, since they tend to make navigation more difficult than
necessary and are often confusing.)  There are many other situations
that would be just as confusing.

Tom Aman

Aman Software
http://www.cyberspyder.com


-------------------------------------------------------
The LED Digest is sponsored by pair Networks:
pair.com for Hosting | pairNIC.com for Domains

Copyright 1995-2006 Orange Wheel, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

"Grant me an old man's frenzy,
Myself must I remake
Till I am Timon and Lear
Or that William Blake
Who beat upon the wall
Till Truth obeyed his call;" - William Butler Yeats