Marketing & SEO Discussion List - LED Digest

Home arrow Full Issues arrow 2004 archives arrow LED Digest 1727: Banner Exchanges in 2004
LED Digest 1727: Banner Exchanges in 2004 Print E-mail
==================================================
                The LED Digest
            Moderated Discussion List
    "Effective Online Advertising, Since 1997"

        pair Networks: The LED's Web Host
  Hosting and Domain Reg. from a Trusted Leader
 pair.com for Hosting  |  pairNIC.com for Domains

==================================================
List Moderator:                      Published by:
Adam Audette                            LED Digest
adam,led-digest.com      http://www.led-digest.com
.................................................
January 13, 2003                       Issue #1727
.................................................


           .....IN THIS DIGEST.....


==== CONTINUING =================

        --== Banner Exchanges in 2004 ==--

                ~ Tom Anson
"From my experience, I'd have to say that you
should stay away from them."

                ~ Ivan Jimenez
"bCentral HAD a great banner exchange program
until they decided to make changes."

        --== Ad Blocking Software ==--

                ~ Sheryl Coppenger
"Take a good hard look at your site from a
consumer point of view..."

                ~ Rick Gortatowsky
"All web browsers will be strapped with this
functionality..."

        --== Affiliate Programs & Partnerships ==--

                ~ Mark Whitman
"...what would happen if you *required* affiliates to
post links to your site exclusively from a newsletter?"


==== BILLBOARD ===================

        --== Selling Whois Data ==--
                ~ Nancy Cardinali

        --== Copycats ==--
                ~ A. Brantley


===== CONTINUING =================================

From: Tom Anson
Subject: Banner exchanges

> Are banner exchanges still popular? If so, can
> anyone recommend a good banner exchange to join?
        - Michael Colucci, LED 1726

Michael Colucci asked if banner exchanges are still popular.  From
my experience, I'd have to say that you should stay away from them.

I used to belong to a bCentral banner exchange.  I didn't want to
clutter my website with banners -- so many of them at the time were
really tacky, with flashing graphics, etc -- so I just purchased
banner placements.  As far as I could tell, I never received any
business from them.  None.

I now have software that even blocks banners -- and it's fairly
popular software.

I've seen web rings or link exchanges, as well.  I can't see these
as helpful, either.

Your best bet is optimizing your site and working on getting
incoming links from related / complimentary sites, or relevant
directories.  There really are no short-cuts.

Tom Anson

Anson Aromatic Essentials
http://www.therapeutic-grade.com


------- new post - same topic -------

From: Ivan Jimenez
Subject: Banner Exchanges

Michael,

Microsoft bCentral HAD a great banner exchange program until they
decided to make changes. Many LEDers lost tons of potential traffic
and Microsoft did nothing to offset the loss. If you're confident
this won't happen again, go to http://www.bcentral.com

If you want a better program with a better exchange, go to Banners
Go MLM http://bannersgomlm.com/ -- I discovered this on a tip from
last year's LED Digest.

Ivan J. Jimenez
CosmicBreath


------- new post - new topic -------

From: Sheryl Coppenger
Subject: Ad blockers

> Do viewers have the right to install software that
> defaces their view of your site and removes your
> revenue generation mechanisms?
        - Marty Milette, LED 1722

I'm not surprised that some of the people on the list are upset
about the Symantec ad blockers.  But I am rather disappointed that
there is so much hostility to the potential customer.

To turn the discussion around -- if there weren't a problem, do you
think Symantec would be able to sell enough of these packages to
cause you heartburn?

Chances are that most of the people bought the package trying to
block popups.  Anybody who has had to restart their computer after
it has been hung by a pop-up-happy web site will understand the
impulse.

It seems to me that if you can detect the package the solution is
pretty simple.  When you notice that someone is using it, just put
up a page that explains (in simple, non-judgemental language) that
people can't see your pages with that feature enabled.

And get your own house in order.  Take a good hard look at your site
from a consumer point of view and make sure you're not part of the
problem that is creating a market for the Symantec product.

Sheryl Coppenger, SEAS Computing Facility Staff

The George Washington University
http://www.seas.gwu.edu/~sheryl


------- new post - same topic -------

From: Rick Gortatowsky
Subject: Ad Blocking

I hate to be the bearer of bad news but no, it's not illegal for
someone to use software to block the ads. In fact, purposefully
circumventing their tools to block unwanted ads is questionable but
probably not pursuable.

This is all going to change. As spam legislation takes hold the
sites that spring unsolicited advertising will be the next targets
perhaps even included in the spam legislation and possible privacy
acts being discussed in high level channels at least in US
Government.

In fact, again I hate to be the bearer of bad news as I respect the
advertising business affiliates out there, we have had many support
our site over the years as well as other retailers we work with as
points of sale we drop ship for.

You are going to see "anti-pop up" controls in browsers themselves
as well as more advertising controls and anti-spam tools. Opera for
example can eliminate Pop Up's from ever activating via one menu
selection.

All web browsers will be strapped with this functionality probably
as soon as the next major release candidates.

Rick Gortatowsky
Software Society


------- new post - new topic -------

From: Mark Whitman
Subject: Affiliate programs

> ... It makes no sense to give users lots of reasons
> to leave your site by means of affiliate links in hopes
> of a relatively meager affiliate commission.
        - Mark Whitman, LED 1724

> How *dare* Mark say that this "proven" online concept "makes no
> sense"? If the better-quality, content-rich sites took his advice,
> I would be left only with crappy, misleadingly promoted affiliate
> farm sites as possible partners.
        - David Yancey, LED 1726

Consider this... what would happen if you *required* affiliates to
post links to your site exclusively from a newsletter? Take it yet a
step further and add the condition that the affiliate include a
personal recommendation to users to benefit from your product.

So what your affiliates would be required to do is deliver a
newsletter (or any sort of opt-in email) that includes their
personal recommendation to use your product along with your
strongest tagline (slogan, whatever) and a text link to your site.

Your assumption was that you'd have nothing but "affiliate farm
sites" as affiliates. Do affiliate farm sites typically offer
newsletters? Even if they did would anyone have a compelling reason
to sign up for it?

My experience tells me no, the typical affiliate farm site does not
offer the user anything useful enough to warrant a newsletter. I
realize there are exceptions, I'm just painting a picture with broad
strokes here.

So who would your typical affiliates be? Your target affiliates
would operate sites that offer useful content to targeted users and
would have an ongoing relationship with those users by means of some
opt-in vehicle.

You're obviously aware of the value of "lifetime relationships". You
would in essence be targeting site operators who have lifetime
relationships with targeted users already in place. That
relationship holds a powerful potential for you as an advertiser.

Of course nothing's for sure until it's tested but my experience
suggests that the end result would be that you'd get more highly
targeted click throughs that are more likely to convert to sales
than you'd get from any other source, bar none.

Combine this strategy with the suggestion that you offer a toolbar
and you *may* have gotten as much value out of this newsletter for
free as you got from the "the most experienced brains in affiliate
sales networking" for mucho dinero.

Mark Whitman


==== BILLBOARD ====================================

From: Nancy Cardinali
Subject: Whois info for sale?

Here's an email I have received twice. I have no intention of
buying, but it seems a little strange. This topic has been touched
on before. Anything new to add?

Begin forwarded message:

------------------------
From: Ann Stoddard
Subject: Re: Fresh WhoIs data (emails, phones, etc.) on sale!

We are offering fresh WhoIs data on 214,000 business websites. Along
with the WhoIs data comes an add-on of email addresses and phone
numbers extracted directly from the contact pages of the mentioned
214,000 businesses.

The WhoIs data includes all the fields provided at registration:
owner/registrar, administrative, technical contacts (emails, phones,
addresses); domain expiry date, creation date, time of last update;
domain servers.

We are also able to download the WhoIs data for any other selection
of domains as well. The data was collected in the period of December
17-23, 2003 and will be updated every 3 months.

Sincerely,
Ann Stoddard
------------------------

Nancy Cardinali


------- new post - new topic -------

From: A. Brantley
Subject: Need Advise Re Copycat

I have discovered that a competitor has bought a domain that is very
close to mine in name, then copied my meta tags and statement at the
bottom of my pages soliciting new products verbatim, changing only
the single word difference in the site names to their site.

Any suggestions what I can do about this blatant traffic hijacking
and copyright infringement?

Thank you,

A. Brantley


-------------------------------------------------------
The LED Digest is sponsored by pair Networks:
pair.com for Hosting | pairNIC.com for Domains

Copyright 1995-2003 Adam Audette. All Rights Reserved.

"We first make our habits, and then our habits make us."
- John Dryden